Reflection
September 2001
Above the World Trade Center
From thirty thousand feet, the smoke was still visible—and so was the need to name what remained worth defending.
New York / in flight A first-person account from the Police Chaplain Project oral-history archive.
SHARE THIS ACCOUNT
THE ACCOUNT
On a flight home, Chief Deputy Bobby Duvall looked down on the remains of the World Trade Center. A newly naturalized citizen spoke about what America meant to her; a flight attendant sang; strangers cried together. His reflection turns from destruction toward public service, shared grief and moral resolve.
“The good and the noble things are worth fighting for.”Chief Deputy Bobby Duvall
WHAT THIS DAY TAUGHT
Lessons to carry forward
Collective grief appears in ordinary places
A cabin became a temporary community of mourners. Leaders should expect emotion to surface away from formal services and allow simple acts of acknowledgment.
Meaning can steady people after shock
Duvall’s reflection returned to service and constitutional ideals. Values can orient a team when offered with humility rather than used to close down grief.
Witness precedes interpretation
The sight of smoke from above gave physical scale to a national loss. Before drawing lessons, make room to describe what was seen and felt.
Public service carries a moral vocabulary
Words such as duty, nobility and the common good help some responders place sacrifice within a larger story. Chaplains can invite that language without prescribing it.
THE FIELD BRIEF
For the next command meeting
Before
- Know the values language used by the people you serve.
- Prepare leaders for grief outside formal settings.
- Protect space for personal and civic meaning.
During
- Let witness and emotion come before explanation.
- Use ceremony only when it serves the people present.
- Invite meaning without demanding agreement.
After
- Record first-person accounts while memory is fresh.
- Connect public ideals to concrete care.
- Return to values without using them to bypass grief.
Use this page to open a tabletop conversation. Adapt every action to local policy, incident command and the needs of the people involved.
01
SEND A PRIVATE REFLECTION
What does this account bring up for you?
Chaplains, officers and family members are welcome to leave a reflection. It comes straight to our team and isn’t published on this page.