Terrorism
October 27, 2018
The Pittsburgh Synagogue Shooting
The injury moved through officers, families and a faith community already carrying a long history of threat.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania A first-person account from the Police Chaplain Project oral-history archive.
SHARE THIS ACCOUNT
THE ACCOUNT
Speaking the next day, Rabbi Marie Betcher held two realities together: officers had run toward gunfire, and a Jewish community had been attacked in worship. Her immediate reflection reveals the layers of identification that can intensify trauma—and the need for solidarity that lasts beyond the vigil.
“We’re intertwined. We have to stand together.”Rabbi Marie Betcher
WHAT THIS DAY TAUGHT
Lessons to carry forward
Honor the act without idealizing the person
Remembering that officers ran toward gunfire can restore context after a devastating event. Support should still leave room for fear, injury and imperfection.
Trauma can feel personal before it is processed
Responders may see a parent, grandparent, child or their own community in a victim. Care should ask about identification and meaning, not only physical proximity.
Language influences help-seeking
Betcher described post-traumatic stress as an injury. Framing a response as an understandable consequence of exposure can reduce shame and open a path to care.
Targeted violence requires enduring solidarity
The response to antisemitic violence cannot end with ceremony. Security planning, interfaith relationships and continued presence tell an affected community it has not been left alone.
THE FIELD BRIEF
For the next command meeting
Before
- Know faith-community leaders before an attack.
- Prepare culturally informed family and funeral support.
- Train chaplains to ask about personal identification with victims.
During
- Coordinate with the affected faith community.
- Protect sacred practice and family privacy.
- Support officers injured physically and psychologically.
After
- Sustain contact after vigils and funerals.
- Use injury language that reduces stigma.
- Include targeted-community security in long-term recovery.
Use this page to open a tabletop conversation. Adapt every action to local policy, incident command and the needs of the people involved.
07
SEND A PRIVATE REFLECTION
What does this account bring up for you?
Chaplains, officers and family members are welcome to leave a reflection. It comes straight to our team and isn’t published on this page.